Sunday, April 11, 2010

Joe Dodge: Brubeck's Other Drummer

My first introduction to the Dave Brubeck Quarter's first drummer, Joe Dodge, came about when I purchased The Essential Dave Brubeck a few years ago. I had assumed that the drum chair on this 31 track CD set was Joe Morello. I marveled at the wide range of drumming styles, only to discover later that while Morello was on many of them, Joe Dodge (among other drummers) was on many of the tracks as well.

This knowledge started a quest to find out more about Joe Dodge. The most detailed resource is Joe Dodge: The Drummer as Time-Keeper from Steven Cerra's excellent blog, Jazz Profiles. As a side note, almost every time I need information about relatively obscure musicians I invariably find it in Mr. Cerra's blog.

While reading Cerra's account of Dodge, it became apparent why Paul Desmond was so incensed when Brubeck hired Morello. That story is well told in When drummer Joe Morello joined the Dave Brubeck Quartet, which was excerpted from Paul Ramsey's Take Five: The Public and Private Lives of Paul Desmond.

Here are a few clips of Dodge in action with the Dave Brubeck Quarter circa 1956:




Dodge is straight ahead and low key, which is a direct contrast to Morello's playing. I love them both, but for different reasons. Morello certainly raised the bar in jazz drumming, but Dodge's restrained drumming complemented Paul Desmond's playing better - and I have always held that Desmond was the heart and soul of the Quartet.

It's probably not a little surprising that after Desmond struck out on his own that he chose Connie Kay for the drum chair. Kay's tasteful and restrained drumming was similar to Dodge's approach, and complemented Desmond's saxophone in ways that Morello's playing didn't.

Lest you get the impression that I am criticizing Morello, know that I consider him to be among the top ten drummers in history, and thoroughly enjoy his playing. Here is Take the A Train with Morello in the drum chair - contrast it with the way Dodge played it in the clip after it to see the differences in their approaches. Both renditions are excellent, and both are valid. My preference is Dodge's playing:

Joe Morello

Joe Dodge

If you want to hear more Joe Dodge and the early incarnation of the Dave Brubeck Quartet, I recommend Jazz: Red, Hot and Cool, as well as Jazz Goes to College. These two albums have live tracks that showcase Dodge's drumming style and how it supported Desmond.

5 comments:

Unknown said...

I remember in junior high the guys who looked like Brubeck, Desmond, Dodge or Morello were considered nerds and ostracised by the "cool" kids. Then I see Dave Brubeck's group. Later I read that Desmond was quite a ladies man and dated models. It turned my concept of what is cool upside down. Morello is one of my favorite drummers but it is nice to see video of Dodge.

Prentice Slaten said...

When I was a kid growing up in San Francisco in the mid-50's, my best friend was Jeff Dodge, Joe Dodge's son. The family lived in an apartment on Russian Hill. I always felt there was something different and special about them. I'm sure it was "Cool." Mr. Dodge left the group and the family moved to Sharp Park. I visited Jeff there a couple of times but we eventually lost track of each other and that was it. Thanks for your post.

Mike Tarrani said...

Thank you Prentice!!!!

George Neidorf said...

in the mid-fifties I was 14 and living in Cincinnati, oh. bruebeck came to town and I went to hear him. there were no seats left in the theater and the usher told me I could sit in one of the seats on stage for the overflow crowd and I got to sit next to joe dodge for the concert. I remember his swing was palpable, something i never felt from morello.

Naomi said...

I so appreciate this article and the following comments. I am Joe Dodge's daughterrowing up surrounded by his talent and that of his musician friends was a priceless kind of cool.
My dad passed away back in August of 2004 and I still miss him. But, not everyone is blessed to be able to "visit" and listen to their departed parent, the my family and I are!